massive Blue View's Tony DelGenio tries on Friday morning to determine whether or not the ny Giants acquired reasonable value from the Kansas Chiefs in return for Kadarius Toney.
In certainty, I'm amazed at what GM Joe Schoen bought in return for Toney.
considering that Toney's lack of availability over 24 games, 12 of which he missed, and the regular questions about his dependability and maturity, I wasn't bound the Giants were even going to be able to dump Toney. The indisputable fact that they got a Day 2 pick — even an extremely late Day 2 decide upon in the 2023 NFL Draft — stunned me. Toney's price interestingly had now not depreciated as tons as i assumed.
Former NFL GM Michael Lombardi wasn't as surprised as i was.
"He has skill. americans pay for ability," Lombardi advised me. "Plus, it's essentially a fourth-rounder."
true enough.
issue was, Toney wasn't suit satisfactory, mature ample, dependable ample to actually display that skill — aside from one online game — for the Giants. even if that game he received ejected for the immature act of taking a swing at an opposing defender.
I all the time believed, and still do consider, that the Giants did the correct component philosophically when Dave Gettleman made the trade down from No. eleven to No. 20 a 12 months ago — the first exchange down he had ever made. The Giants don't have had the possibility to make two selections within the proper 10 of this year's draft without that circulate, so as a minimum one of Kayvon Thibodeaux and Evan Neal would not be on the team. They wouldn't have Aaron Robinson or Daniel Bellinger. The alternate introduced them lots.
The problem changed into they chosen the inaccurate player at No. 20.
appear on the avid gamers chosen between No. 20 and No. 50, where the Giants took Azeez Ojulari, and there are a number of productive avid gamers the Giants could have selected. shoot, even taking Ojulari at 20 and Toney at 50 if he become nonetheless obtainable would have reduced the sting.
Toney's time with the Giants changed into odd from the first day he set foot on a convention box in rookie mini-camp, when an apparent cleat problem left him practicing with one shoe off. He skipped OTAs — whatever beginners on no account do — had COVID-19 twice, had a couple of social media incidents, and had hamstring, quad, ankle, indirect and shoulder accidents. He played 10 video games.
This yr, he skipped the beginning of OTAs, overlooked the rest of spring practices after having minor knee surgical procedure, suffered three separate hamstring accidents beginning in working towards camp, performed in two video games and contributed ZERO yards receiving and 23 yards rushing to the Giants' offense.
In our poll, eighty five p.c of voters concept the Giants did the appropriate element through trading Toney.
ballot Do you approve of the Giants' alternate of Kadarius Toney?This ballot is closed
6238 votes complete Vote NowI don't believe Schoen and head coach Brian Daboll would have drafted Toney, however they came to the Giants with an open mind. They gave everybody, together with Toney, a clear slate. gamers like Oshane Ximines, David Sills and others took expertise of that. Toney didn't.
The ultimate straw apparently came this week. Toney, who only in the near past stated he notion he had returned too soon from his closing hamstring damage, interestingly felt ready to return to follow this week. He interestingly objected to being held off form Wednesday and requested to remain in New Jersey all the way through the bye week to continue rehabbing his latest harm.
Paul Schwartz of the manhattan post reported Toney's sadness. right here is a component of what he wrote:
It is probably going Toney, who has neglected the previous 5 games with two separate hamstring accidents, passes his actual in Kansas metropolis. The plan for him with the Giants turned into to observe on Thursday and, if all went neatly, most likely play Sunday in Seattle.
The Giants, though, truly favored Toney take a seat out this online game and relaxation up all through right here bye week to be suit for the 2nd half of the season. The NFL alternate deadline is Tuesday and the Giants have been no longer dedicated to holding him around. If he played and re-injured himself, his trade value would be diminished. If he performed and became productive, his marketability in a trade would boost. Given his history with the Giants ever for the reason that becoming a 2021 first-circular decide upon, the feeling changed into it was greater possible Toney would hurt his exchange cost.
Toney, in keeping with a source, changed into no longer chuffed that he changed into held off form Wednesday. He believed he became able to go. The present from the Chiefs got here early Thursday and that changed into that.
it is believed Daboll's plan is for the injured avid gamers to dwell in town right through the bye week and continue their rehab on the group facility. If Toney changed into held out of Sunday's game he would had been considered an injured participant and required to live — which he would no longer need to do. there have been concerns that Toney, if deemed healthy, would depart the enviornment and compromise a few of his conditioning during the bye week, making him greater liable to injury upon his return. obviously, Toney didn't construct up any trust fairness with the new coaching body of workers or front workplace.
Toney reacted to the alternate by way of tweeting that he turned into "not damage," then apparently deleting that tweet.
Daboll wasn't biting Friday when requested to touch upon Toney's claim of not being harm:
for my part, what Toney does in Kansas metropolis — with a pretty good quarterback in Patrick Mahomes and a very good offensive instruct in Andy Reid — is beside the point. It wasn't going to happen with the Giants.
there is loads of speculation, together with right here at huge Blue View, concerning the Giants in all probability the usage of the outlet and the cap area created with the aid of the Toney deal, to swing a deal for Denver Broncos' broad receiver Jerry Jeudy.
that could work as a result of Jeudy incorporates most effective a $1.991 million cap hit this season and is also beneath contract for 2023. The Giants would get a 23-12 months-historical participant who would improve their extensive receiver ability and be more than a half-season improve.
Does Schoen want to half with the draft capital to get that achieved, or put it aside and go into the draft where he might find a younger receiver or two he could have on full 4-year rookie contracts?
i suspect it is going to emerge as being the latter, but when the price isn't exorbitant I wouldn't blame him for making the circulate.
Post a Comment